in time or place. 2d. Cause and effect. 3d. Resemblance or contrariety.*

Under these heads may be correctly classed, the various causes of that fanciful agreement which produce risible emotions. I. Under

that of contiguity we may arrange,

1st. Bodily singularities, including a grotesque dress or manner.

2d. Groups of contrasted figures, such as an old popular caricature which I remember, of "A Macaroni Alderman and his Rib." The one a squat bloated figure dressed in the extravagance of/fashion, the other an extremely tall and meagre female in a dress remarkably prim and formal. I may instance another which is yet popular, "A country Clown placed between a Counsellor and an Attorney.'

3d. A confused assemblage of incongruous ideas, such as often takes place in a play to which you used to be partial, Cross Purposes; and in the cross readings of the newspaper columns. Of this kind of humour some excellent specimens were afforded by the writers of the Rolliad, the Probationary Odes, &c.

4th. Meanness and dignity brought together

* See the Economy of Nature, b. x. c. 4.

in contact. Under this head we may class the anticlimax, and what the writers of Martinus Scriblerus style the bathos-one of the happiest specimens of which is,

"And thou Dalhousie, the great god of war,
"Lieutenant-colonel to the earl of Mar."

Perhaps I might add a specimen from Mr. Pope himself

"Grac❜d as thou art with all the pow'r of words, ·
"So known, so honour'd in the house of Lords."

II. Under cause and effect we may place, 1st. Ironical reasoning, and much also of what is called analogical reasoning, which is often as ridiculous as fanciful. As for instance

"What does it signify (quoth Albertus) whether my nephew exceeds in the cursus or not? Speed is often a symptom of cowardice, witness hares and deer."-MEM. OF MART. SCRIB.

2d. Cause and effect not corresponding with each other-whence

3d. Ridiculous hyperbole and rant—

“Behold a scene of misery and woe!

"Here Argus soon might weep himself quite blind, "Ev'n though he had Briareus hundred hands,

To wipe those hundred eyes.”

*He roar'd so loud, and look'd so wondrous grim, "His very shadow durst not follow him."

4th. Much of what is called caricature

"Some have been beaten till they know
"What wood a cudgel's of by the blow;
"Some kick'd, until they can feel whether
"A shoe be Spanish or neat's leather."

HUD. p. ii. l. 2..

III. But of all the relations that of resemblance is the most fruitful of ludicrous ideas.

1st. Of these, the more fanciful and unexpected the resemblance, the greater in general will be the effect. Thus Butler describes the

horse of his hero :

"The beast was sturdy, large, and tall,
"With mouth of meal and eyes of wali;
"I would say eye, for h’ad but one,
"As most agree, though some say none.
"He was well stay'd, and in his gait,
"Preserv'd a grave majestic state.
"At spur or switch no more he skipt,
"Nor mended pace, than Spaniard whipt;
"And yet so fiery, he would bound,
"As if he griev❜d to touch the ground;
"Thus Cæsar's horse, who as fame goes,,

"Had corns upon his feet and toes,
"Was not by half so tender hooft,

Nor trod upon the ground so soft.

"And as that beast would kneel and stoop

86

(Some write) to take his rider up;

"So Hudibras his ('tis well-known)

"Would often do to set him down."

The whole spirit of this passage, you will easily see, depends on the allusions. The majestic state of the horse, which scorned to mend his pace, contrasted with the tenderness of his feet, and the comparison with that of Cæsar, are highly ludicrous.

Contrariety or contrast, is classed under the

same head of association, by logical writers, as resemblance, and of the witty application of this we have a fine instance in the four last lines which I have just quoted; and in the following from Swift's verses on his death.

68

My female friends, whose tender hearts
"Have better learn'd to act their parts,
"Receive the news in doleful dumps:
"The Dean is dead (pray what is trumps?)
"The Lord have mercy on his soul!
"(Ladies I'll venture for the vole).
"Six deans they say must bear his pall,
" (I wish I knew what king to call).

Madam, your husband will attend
"The fun'ral of so good a friend?
"No madam, 'tis a shocking sight,
"And he's engag'd to-morrow night:

"My Lady Club would take it ill,
"If he should fail her at quadrille.
"He lov'd the Dean (I lead a heart);

"But dearest friends, they say, must part."

The most fruitful source of the burlesque and the mock-heroic is, when the allusion is from the great to the mean or little.

"The Greeks renowned, so Homer writes,
"For well-soaled boots, as well as fights."-HUD.

The order is reversed, however, in some instances of the mock-heroic, as in the Lutrin of Boileau, and the charming Rape of the Lock.

"This nymph, to the destruction of mankind,
"Nourish'd two locks, which graceful hung behind
“In equal curls, and well conspir'd to deck
"With shining ringlets the smooth iv'ry neck.
"Love in these labyrinths her slaves detains,
"And mighty hearts are held in slender chains.
"With hairy springes we the birds betray,
"Slight lines of hair surprise the finny prey ;
"Fair tresses man's imperial race ensnare,
"And beauty draws us with a single hair.”

In these lines, and in all the poem, a slight circumstance is magnified into something of apparent importance. The card party is an admirable instance in point