which remains to him. No such agreement among mankind could ever have possibly taken place; for man is by his nature, and without any agreement, a social being. He is a being whose rights are balanced by the uncontrollable force of their relation to the rights of others. The succor which the infant man requires from its parents, to an extent, and for a duration, so much exceeding that required for the nurture of other creatures, is the natural beginning of the social state, established insensibly and by degrees. The liberty which the social man is thus compelled by the force of circumstances to renounce amounts only to a restraint upon his brute power of doing injury to his fellowmen and for this sacrifice, in itself the cause of the highest individual and therefore general good, he obtains that dominion over every other being, and that control over the productive forces of nature, which alone can render him the monarch of all he surveys. The poor sailor, who for four years was cut off from human aid, and left alone to struggle for the means of supporting existence, was an exception, and a very rare one, to the condition of our species all over the world. His absolute rights placed him in the condition of uncontrolled feebleness; if he had become social, he would have put on the regulated strength of rights balanced by duties.

Alexander Selkirk was originally left upon the unin habited island of Juan Fernandez at his own urgent desire. He was unhappy on board his ship, in consequence of disputes with his captain; and he resolved to rush into a state which might probably have separated him forever from the rest of mankind. In the belief that he should be so separated, he devoted all his labor and all his ingenuity to the satisfaction of his own wants alone. By continual exercise, he was enabled to run down the wild goat upon the mountains; and by persevering search, he knew where to find

ALEXANDER SELKIRK.

41

the native roots that would render his goat's flesh palatable. He never thought, however, of providing any store beyond the supply of his own personal necessities. He had no motive for that thought; because there was no human being within his reach with whom he might exchange that store for other stores. The very instant, however, that the English ships, which finally gave him back to society, touched upon his shores-before he communicated by speech with any of his fellow-men, or, was discovered by them-he became social. He saw that he must be an exchanger. Before the boat's crew landed he had killed several goats, and prepared a meal for his expected guests. He knew that he possessed a commodity which they did not possess. He had fresh meat, while they had only salt provisions. Of course what he had to offer was acceptable to the sailors; and he received in exchange protection, and a place among them. He renounced his sovereignty, and became once more a subject. It was better for him, he thought, to be surrounded with the regulated power of civilization, than to wield at his own will the uncertain strength of solitary uncivilization. But, had he chosen to remain upon his island, as in after-years he regretted he had not done, although a solitary man he would not have been altogether cut off from the hopes and the duties of the social state. If he had chosen to remain after that visit from his fellowmen, he would have said to them, before they had left him once more alone, "I have hunted for you my goats, I have dug for you my roots, I have shown you the fountains which issue out of my rocks; these are the resources of my dominion: give me in exchange for them a fresh supply of gunpowder and shot, some of your clothes, some of the means of repairing these clothes, some of your tools and implements of cookery, and more of your books to divert my solitary hours." Having enjoyed the benefits which he had

bestowed, they would, as just men, have paid the debt which they had incurred, and the exchange would have been completed. Immediately that they had quitted his shores, Selkirk would have looked at his resources with a new eye. His hut was rudely fashioned and wretchedly furnished. He had fashioned and furnished it as well as he could by his own labor, working upon his own materials. The visit which he had received from his fellow-men, after he had abandoned every hope of again looking upon their faces, would have led him to think that other ships would come, with whose crews he might make other exchangesnew clothes, new tools, new materials, received as the price of his own accumulations. To make the best of his circumstances when that day should arrive, he must redouble his efforts to increase his stock of commodities-some for himself, and some to exchange for other commodities, if the opportunity for exchange should ever come. He must,

DANIEL DEFOE.

therefore, transplant his vegetables, so as to be within instant reach when they should be wanted. He must render his goats domestic, instead of chasing them upon the hills. He must go forward from the hunting state, into the pastoral and agricultural.

In Defoe's story, Rob-. inson Crusoe is represented as going into this pastoral and agri

cultural state. But he had more resources than Selkirk;

ROBINSON CRUSOE.

43

and he at last obtained one resource which carried him back, however incompletely, into the social condition. He acquired a fellow-laborer. He made a boat by his unassisted labor; but he could not launch it. When Friday came, and was henceforth his faithful friend and willing servant, he could launch his boat. Crusoe ultimately left his island; for the boat had given him a greater command over his circumstances. But had he continued there in companionship with Friday, there must have been such a compact as would have prevented either struggling for the property which had been created. The course of improvement that we have imagined for Selkirk supposes that he should continue in his state of exclusive proprietorthat there should be none to dispute his right. If other ships had come to his shores-if they had trafficked with him from time to time-exchanged clothes and household conveniences, and implements of cultivation, for his goats' flesh and roots-it is probable that other sailors would in time have desired to partake his plenty; that a colony would have been founded; that the island would have become populous. It is perfectly clear that, whether for exchange among themselves, or for exchange with others, the members of this colony could not have stirred a step in the cultivation of the land without appropriating its produce; and they could not have appropriated its produce without appropriating the land itself. Cultivation of the land for a common stock would have conduced to the establishment of precisely the same principle: they would still have been exchangers among themselves, and the partnership would not have lasted a day, unless each man's share of what the partnership produced had been rendered perfectly secure to him. Without security they could not have accumulated; without accumulations they could not have exchanged; without exchanges they could not have

carried forward their labors with any compensating productiveness.

Imperfect appropriation-that is, an appropriation which respects personal wealth, such as the tools and conveniences

ROBINSON CRUSOE.-(FROM A DESIGN BY STOTHARD.)

of an individual, and even secures to him the fruits of the earth when he has gathered them, but which has not reached the last step of a division of land-imperfect ap